Short answer
An SEO audit checks whether Google can find, read and trust your site, and whether the pages match what people search. Start with Search Console, then crawl the site, then check speed, on-page basics, content, local listings and links. Turn what you find into a short list ordered by impact, not a 200-item report.
Most SEO audit checklists are 200 items long, and most of the items don’t matter. The result is a report that says everything is broken, a business owner who doesn’t know where to start, and the one problem that’s actually costing money buried on page forty.
This is the checklist I work from, cut down to the checks that change rankings and enquiries on a typical small business site, in the order I run them. You can do all of it with free tools. I’ve also included the mistakes that make audits wrong, because I’ve seen every one of them in real audits, and a template for turning what you find into a list of jobs.
What does an SEO audit involve?
An SEO audit checks four things: whether Google can find and store your pages, whether it can read and understand them, whether they match what people search for, and whether anything on or off the site is holding them back. The output is a prioritised list of fixes.
In practice that means looking at your site three ways: through Google’s eyes (Search Console), through a crawler’s eyes (a tool that visits every page like a search engine would), and through a customer’s eyes (the page on a phone). Each catches problems the others miss.
The checklist below works for any small business site. For a site with thousands of pages, an online shop with filters, or a migration, the same checks apply but there’s a lot more to each one.
What do you need to run an SEO audit?
Four free tools and about an afternoon: Google Search Console, Google Analytics or your usual analytics, PageSpeed Insights, and the free version of Screaming Frog, which crawls up to 500 URLs. Add your Google Business Profile if you serve a local area.
- Google Search Console. The only place to see what Google has indexed and which searches you appear for. If it isn’t set up, setting it up is step one, and you’ll need to wait a few days for data.
- Analytics. To see which pages bring in visitors who go on to enquire.
- PageSpeed Insights. Speed and Core Web Vitals for real pages.
- Screaming Frog SEO Spider. Free up to 500 URLs, which covers most small business sites. It lists every page’s status, title, headings and links.
- Your phone. Some problems only show up when you use the site like a customer.
How to do an SEO audit, step by step
Export your Search Console data first, then crawl the site using that list, then work through indexing, speed, on-page, content, local and links. Check every finding on the live page before you believe it, then sort the fixes by how much traffic or how many enquiries each one affects.
The order I work in
Export Search Console before anything else
Performance for the last 16 months (the most it keeps), plus the Pages indexing report. Search Console rolls forward daily, so save the exports: next month’s window won’t be the same.
Build the crawl list from Search Console
Every URL Google has shown in results, not just the ones your menu links to. A crawl that starts from the homepage can’t see old addresses or pages nothing links to, and that’s often where the problem is.
Crawl the site
Screaming Frog with your sitemap included. Make sure it doesn’t silently follow redirects, or a redirect and a live page look the same.
Work through the checklist below
Indexing, speed, on-page, content, local, links. Write each finding down with the number behind it: how many pages, how many clicks, which URL.
Check every finding on the live site
Open the page. Look at the real status code, the real heading, the real title. Tool outputs are where audits go wrong.
Sort by impact and write the list
The fix that affects your best-earning pages goes first, even if it’s one line. Group the rest into “next” and “when there’s time”.
The SEO audit checklist
Work through seven groups in order: Search Console and performance, indexing and crawling, speed and mobile, on-page, content, local, and links and trust. Each group below has the checks that most often change results on a small business site.
Tick them off as you go. Each list resets if you reload the page, so keep your notes somewhere else.
1. Search Console and performance
Search Console and performance
0/ 5
That is the whole list. Anything still unticked is your next job.
2. Indexing and crawling
This is the technical SEO audit checklist part, and the one most likely to turn up a serious problem. What is technical SEO? explains each item in more depth.
Indexing and crawling
0/ 7
That is the whole list. Anything still unticked is your next job.
3. Speed and mobile
Speed and mobile
0/ 4
That is the whole list. Anything still unticked is your next job.
4. On-page
On-page
0/ 6
That is the whole list. Anything still unticked is your next job.
5. Content
Content
0/ 5
That is the whole list. Anything still unticked is your next job.
6. Local
If you serve a local area, this is your local SEO audit. What is local SEO? covers each item in detail.
Local
0/ 4
That is the whole list. Anything still unticked is your next job.
7. Links and trust
Links and trust
0/ 4
That is the whole list. Anything still unticked is your next job.
What mistakes make an SEO audit wrong?
Trusting tool output without checking the live page, counting things that aren’t pages, comparing impressions across Google’s September 2025 change, chasing a score out of 100, and listing every warning instead of the few that matter. Each one makes a report look worse, or better, than the site really is.
An audit is a set of claims about your site, so each one needs to be true. These are the mistakes that most often make them false:
- Reading a tool warning as a fact. On one Shopify audit, the crawler reported 102 broken pages. They were 102 “too many requests” responses: the shop was throttling the crawler, and every one of those pages was fine. Slow the crawl down and open the URLs before reporting anything.
- Counting things that aren’t pages. Crawlers pick up search results, filter combinations, login redirects and page fragments. Decide what counts as a real page first, or every issue count is inflated.
- Comparing impressions across September 2025. Around 10 September 2025, Google stopped supporting a setting rank-tracking tools used to load 100 results at once, and impressions in Search Console dropped across the industry as a result. Clicks weren’t affected. If your impressions fell that month, it wasn’t a penalty, and comparing impressions or average position year on year across that date gives you a misleading answer.
- Letting the crawler follow redirects. If the tool follows a redirect and reports the destination, you can’t tell a redirected address from a live duplicate, which is usually the thing you’re trying to find.
- Chasing the score. Scores out of 100 are each tool’s own invention. Google doesn’t use them.
- Recommending pages that already exist. Before writing “build pages for X”, check whether they’re already there and simply not linked to. Pages nothing links to are easy to miss and often already earn traffic.
SEO audit template
Turn the audit into one table: a numbered task, the evidence behind it, where in your admin it gets fixed, and who does it, grouped into “do these first”, “next” and “when there’s time”. If a finding has no number behind it, it isn’t ready to go on the list.
This is the format I hand over at the end of every audit. Copy the columns:
| # | Task | Evidence | Where | Who | Priority |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Redirect non-www to www | 4 versions of the homepage load; 12 pages indexed twice | Hosting or domain settings | Technical | Do first |
| 2 | Remove noindex from the boiler repair page | Page has 0 impressions; noindex tag in the HTML | Page settings in the CMS | In-house | Do first |
| 3 | Rewrite titles on top 10 pages by impressions | 18,000 impressions, 0.4% click rate | Each page’s SEO settings | In-house | Next |
| 4 | Merge three boiler pressure posts into one | 3 posts on the same search, positions 24, 31 and 45 | Blog, plus redirects | In-house | Next |
| 5 | Compress homepage images | Largest image 4.2 MB; LCP 5.1s on mobile | Media library | In-house | When there’s time |
The rows are examples. The point is the evidence column: “titles need improving” isn’t a task, but “rewrite ten titles on pages with 18,000 impressions and a 0.4% click rate” is, because it tells you why it matters and how you’ll know it worked.
If you’d rather have someone run it for you, my SEO audit starts with a free basic review, and the full audit comes with this kind of prioritised list, with the option of having the fixes done too.
Common questions
Can ChatGPT do an SEO audit?
It can explain findings and help you prioritise, but it can't see your Search Console data, crawl your whole site or check what Google has actually indexed unless you give it that data. Tools that fetch a single page often render it differently from how Google sees it, which produces confident findings that are wrong. Use it to make sense of real exports, not instead of them.
How long does an SEO audit take?
Running this checklist on a small business site takes an afternoon. A professional audit of a site with a few hundred pages usually takes days, mostly because every finding has to be checked against the live site before it's reported. What an SEO audit costs covers timings and prices.
How often should you do an SEO audit?
A full audit once a year, or before and after any redesign or move to a new platform. In between, a monthly look at Search Console catches most problems before they cost you anything.
What's the difference between an SEO audit and a website audit?
An SEO audit asks whether the site can be found and ranks for the right searches. A website audit is broader and can also cover design, accessibility, security, conversion and content quality. The two overlap heavily, and most of this checklist belongs in both.
Are free SEO audit tools worth using?
As a starting point, yes. Search Console, PageSpeed Insights and the free version of Screaming Frog cover most of what a small site needs. Be wary of tools that give your site a score out of 100: the score is the tool's own invention, and chasing it can mean fixing things that don't matter.
Want to hand your site over to a professional?
Everything above is yours to run with. If you'd rather someone else ran it, send me the address and I'll tell you what I'd fix first — free, and in plain English.
Get a free SEO audit


