Short answer
Most ranking drops aren't what people assume. Before blaming a Google update, rule out the four things that look identical to one and are far more likely: a measurement artefact rather than a real drop, normal seasonality, a change someone made to your site, and the search results page changing shape above you. Work through them in that order, because each one is cheaper to check than the one after it.
Somebody checks their rankings, sees a page has fallen, and the first thought is always the same: Google must have changed something.
Sometimes it has. But in the audits I’ve run, an algorithm update is nowhere near the most common explanation for a drop — it’s just the most available one, because it’s the one in the headlines that week. Far more often the answer is something much duller, much closer to home, and much cheaper to fix.
So here’s the order I work through it in. Each step is cheaper than the one after it, which is the whole point of the order.
Step 1: work out whether you actually dropped
Start here, because a surprising share of drops don’t survive this step.
Rank trackers check a handful of keywords, from one location, on one device type, at one moment. Google’s results vary by all four. A tracker showing position 4 yesterday and position 9 today may be reporting two genuinely different results pages rather than a change in how Google sees you.
Search Console is the better instrument, because it reports what really happened to real people. Open the Performance report, set the date range to the last three months, and look at clicks and impressions, not average position.
Three patterns, three different problems:
- Clicks down, impressions down. A real visibility drop. Carry on to step 2.
- Clicks down, impressions flat. You’re still appearing, people are choosing someone else. That’s a click-through-rate problem, not a ranking one, and organic CTR covers it properly.
- Clicks flat, traffic down in analytics. Your analytics changed, not your rankings. Consent banners, ad blockers, a tag that stopped firing, a migration to a new analytics property. Check the tracking before anything else.
Step 2: rule out seasonality
Compare like with like. Not this month against last month — this period against the same period last year.
Half the “drops” I get sent are a business whose searches fall every year at the same time and has never had a reason to notice before. Accountants in June. Garden centres in November. Anyone selling to schools, in August. If last year’s chart has the same shape, you haven’t lost rankings; your customers have gone quiet, and they’ll come back.
This matters doubly right now. The November 2026 core update finishes around 24 November, which runs straight into Thanksgiving, Black Friday and Cyber Monday. Any retailer comparing the end of November to the start of it is going to read an enormous seasonal swing as an algorithm effect. Pick a baseline week before 10 November and hold it.
Step 3: ask what changed on your site
This is the one people skip, and it’s the answer more often than the algorithm is.
Sites change constantly, and the person who changed something often isn’t the person watching the rankings. A developer tidied up. A plugin updated. A new theme shipped. Somebody rewrote a page to read better and removed the words people were searching for.
What changed in the two weeks before the drop
0/ 8
That is the whole list. Anything still unticked is your next job.
A redesign is the big one. If rankings fell within a few weeks of a new site going live, that’s almost certainly your cause, and what to protect in a redesign covers what usually goes wrong.
Step 4: look at the results page itself
You can lose clicks without losing a single position.
Google keeps changing the shape of its results. An AI Overview appears above you and pushes the first organic result down the page. A map pack gets added to a query that didn’t have one. A video carousel, a product grid, four ads instead of three. Your page is still ranked third and still gets a third of the clicks it used to.
Search for your own terms and look at what’s above you now. If the answer is “more things than before”, that’s your explanation, and the fix is a positioning problem rather than a ranking one. For queries now answered by AI, AI SEO and what changed in AI Mode are the relevant reading.
The other version of this: a competitor moved. Somebody published something better, or a big brand entered the space. You didn’t get worse, the field got stronger. That’s still a real problem, but it’s a content problem with a known shape.
Step 5: now consider the algorithm
If you’ve got here honestly — the drop is real, it isn’t seasonal, nothing changed on the site, and the results page looks the same — then an algorithm update becomes a reasonable explanation.
Two checks:
- Does the date line up? Google logs every confirmed update on its Search Status Dashboard with start and end dates. If your drop began on a day in a rollout window, that’s evidence. If it began three weeks before the update started, the update didn’t cause it, however tempting the story is.
- Did it hit everything or something? Core updates tend to move whole sections of a site, because they’re revisions to how a type of content gets judged. A drop confined to one page is usually that page’s problem.
If it is a core update, the response isn’t the one most people reach for, and it’s long enough to need its own piece: what to do after a core update.
The quick version
Check clicks, not average position
Search Console Performance, three months. If clicks are steady, you may not have a problem at all.
Compare to the same period last year
Seasonality explains a large share of drops, and it explains them completely.
Find out what changed on the site
Ask everyone with access. Check indexing, noindex, redirects, speed and the page text itself.
Look at the results page
AI Overviews, map packs and new competitors all cost you clicks without costing you position.
Then check the update dashboard
If and only if the date lines up and the drop is broad rather than one page.
Most of this is free and takes an afternoon. If you’ve been through it all and still can’t account for the drop, that’s the point at which paying someone makes sense — what to ask before you hire anyone covers how to avoid the people who’ll tell you it was the algorithm without checking any of the above.
Common questions
How far can rankings move normally without anything being wrong?
A page bouncing between positions 6 and 11 week to week is ordinary. Google re-ranks constantly, and the lower down you are the wider the swing, because the differences between pages are smaller down there. A drop is worth investigating when it's sustained across several weeks and shows up in clicks, not just in a rank tracker.
How long should I wait before doing anything?
Two weeks of data at minimum, and longer if a core update is rolling out, because positions move during a rollout and then move again before they settle. Acting on three days of data is how a small dip becomes a real problem — you change five things, the dip was noise, and now you can't tell what any of the changes did.
My rankings dropped but my traffic is the same. What does that mean?
Usually that your rank tracker and your actual visitors disagree, and the visitors are the ones telling the truth. Trackers check from one location on one device type. Search Console reports what really happened across everyone. If clicks and impressions are steady, you probably haven't lost anything worth chasing.
Can a Google review or bad press cause a ranking drop?
Reviews don't directly move your website's organic rankings, though they matter a lot for the map pack. A sudden drop in local pack visibility usually traces back to your Google Business Profile — a category change, a suspension, an address edit — rather than to your website at all.
Should I hire someone to work out why my rankings dropped?
Not until you've checked the free things. Search Console tells you most of what an audit would, and a consultant worth paying will ask for that data first anyway. If you've worked through this list and still can't explain it, that's the point where outside help earns its money — and what to ask for is covered in how to hire an SEO consultant.
Want to hand your site over to a professional?
Everything above is yours to run with. If you'd rather someone else ran it, send me the address and I'll tell you what I'd fix first — free, and in plain English.
Get a free SEO audit


