What makes a good website? The 10 things that actually win customers

What makes a good website for a small business? The 10 qualities that bring in enquiries, the pages it needs, how to test your own site, and what to drop.

Mike ArnoldPublished 13 min read

Short answer

A good website gets found on Google, loads fast on a phone, says clearly what you do, where and roughly what it costs, gives people reasons to trust you, and makes the next step easy. How it looks matters far less than whether it does those jobs, and whether someone keeps it up to date.

Ask a web designer what makes a good website and you’ll usually hear about layout, colour and typefaces. Ask the business that paid for it and the answer is simpler: does it bring in work?

The two aren’t the same. One of the sites I’ve worked on belonged to a London surveying practice with over a hundred pages of expert writing. It looked fine and nothing was obviously broken, and it was getting about six visits a day from Google. A good website is judged by what it does, not by how it looks in the designer’s portfolio. Here are the ten things I check, the pages a small business site needs, and a quick way to test your own.

What makes a good website?

A good website gets found on Google, loads quickly on a phone, tells visitors straight away what you do, where, and roughly what it costs, gives them reasons to trust you, and makes the next step easy. Design supports those jobs; it doesn’t replace them.

Think about what someone wants when they land on a small business website. They’ve searched for something, usually on their phone, and they’re deciding in a few seconds whether you’re worth a call. They want to know:

  1. Is this what I’m looking for? The service, in plain words.
  2. Do they cover where I am? The town or area.
  3. Can I afford it? A price, a range, or at least “from”.
  4. Are they any good? Reviews, photos of real work, a real person’s name.
  5. How do I get in touch? A phone number they can tap, and a short form.

A site that answers those five quickly is a good website, whatever it looks like. A beautiful site that makes people hunt for them isn’t.

The 10 qualities of a good website

The ten qualities that matter most for a small business site are: it’s found on Google, it’s fast on a phone, it’s clear what you do, it has a page for each service, it shows prices, it proves you’re trustworthy, it makes contact easy, it’s accessible, it’s kept up to date, and it looks professional.

Here’s the list I work through when I look at a client’s site, in order of how much each one usually costs a business when it’s missing. Tick off the ones your site already does, then read the ten in full below.

Score your own site: how many of the ten does it do?

0/ 10

1. It can be found on Google

The best website in your town earns nothing if it isn’t in the results. That means pages Google has actually indexed, titles that say what each page is about, and a page for each thing people search for rather than one page trying to cover everything.

Start in Search Console. If your main services don’t appear for the searches customers use, nothing further down this list matters yet. If pages are missing from Google entirely, why a website doesn’t show up covers the usual causes, most of which take minutes to fix once you know which one you have.

2. It’s fast on a phone

Test real pages, not just the homepage — the homepage is usually the one page somebody optimised. Run a service page and a blog post through PageSpeed Insights too.

Big uncompressed images are the most common culprit on a small business site, followed by a heavy commercial theme and years of accumulated plugins. Speed is mostly a hosting-and-housekeeping job rather than a design one, which is why it’s covered in what technical SEO actually is.

Why does website speed matter so much?

Because people leave slow sites before they’ve read a word, and most of them are on a phone. Google’s own targets are for the main content to appear within 2.5 seconds, for the page to respond to taps within 200 milliseconds, and for the layout not to jump around while it loads.

Those three targets are Google’s Core Web Vitals: Largest Contentful Paint under 2.5 seconds, Interaction to Next Paint under 200 milliseconds, and Cumulative Layout Shift under 0.1. You don’t need to remember the names. Run a page through PageSpeed Insights and it tells you whether you pass.

The business case is real, even in tenths of a second. Deloitte’s Milliseconds Make Millions study, commissioned by Google, tracked mobile sites across Europe and the US and found that a 0.1-second speed improvement went with:

8.3%better bounce rate on lead generation pages
8.4%more retail conversions
10.1%more travel conversions

Deloitte, Milliseconds Make Millions, 2020. Commissioned by Google; 0.1-second mobile speed improvement.

It matters more in the UK than it might seem. Ofcom’s Online Nation 2025 report found UK adults spend four and a half hours a day online, and that most of that time is on a smartphone. Your site is mostly being read on a small screen, often on mobile data.

3. It’s obvious what you do within five seconds

The first screen should say the service and the area in plain words. “Welcome to our website” and “Solutions for tomorrow” say nothing, and a slider that rotates three messages makes people wait for the one they need.

Write it the way a customer would say it out loud. “Emergency plumber in Stowmarket” beats “Trusted plumbing solutions for the modern home”, because one is a search somebody actually types and the other is a slogan.

4. Each service has its own page

One page per service, written around what customers search and ask, beats one long Services page listing everything. Someone searching for a specific job wants to land on a page about that job, not a list that mentions it in passing.

This is the single biggest structural win on most small business sites, and the one most of them skip. A page written for one specific job will out-earn a general services page that mentions it in passing, because it can answer that job’s questions properly and rank for the search behind it. How to plan content around what people search covers how to decide which pages you actually need.

What pages should a small business website have?

At minimum: a homepage, a page for each service, an about page with real people on it, a contact page, and a page of reviews or examples of your work. Add prices, a page for each area you serve if you cover several towns, and answers to the questions customers ask most.

What a lot of sites haveWhat a good small business site has
Homepage“Welcome to our website” and a slideshowWhat you do, where, a reason to trust you, and how to get in touch
ServicesOne page listing everythingA page for each service, with prices and FAQs
AboutA mission statementReal names, photos, experience and qualifications
ProofThree anonymous testimonialsReviews, photos of real jobs, case studies with numbers
ContactA long form, hidden in the menuA tap-to-call number and a short form on every page

In short: You don’t need more pages than this to start. You need each of these to answer a customer’s question better than your competitors’ do.

If you cover several towns, an area page for each can help, but only where you have something real to say about working there. Fifty pages that only swap the town name don’t make you local anywhere.

5. It gives a price, or at least a starting point

Even “from £450”, a typical range, or what the first visit costs. Without one, people have to guess, and a good share of them guess high and leave without asking.

Publishing prices also filters out the enquiries you don’t want, which is worth as much as winning the ones you do. What a website costs is an example of the format: real numbers, with what moves them up and down.

6. It proves you’re real and good

Reviews, photographs of actual work, a named person, an address or service area, years in business, trade body memberships. A stranger is deciding whether to let you into their house or spend money with you, and they’re looking for reasons to believe you.

This is the practical end of what Google calls experience, expertise, authoritativeness and trust — E-E-A-T explained covers what that means in practice. The short version: show the work, name the people.

7. Getting in touch is easy

A phone number you can tap on a mobile, a short form, and the next step on every page rather than only on the contact page. Long forms asking for information you don’t need yet cost you enquiries at the last hurdle.

If your site gets visitors but the phone doesn’t ring, traffic but no enquiries walks through where people are dropping out and what to do about it.

8. Everyone can use it

Readable text size, enough contrast between text and background, descriptive links instead of “click here”, and alt text on images. The WCAG 2.2 guidelines are the international standard if you want the detail.

It helps disabled visitors, and it helps everyone else too — most of these changes are the same ones that make a page readable on a phone screen in daylight.

9. It’s kept up to date

Current prices, opening hours, staff and services. Secure (https), with the software kept patched. An out-of-date site reads like an out-of-business one, and a visitor who spots last year’s prices stops trusting the rest of the page.

This is the quality that decays on its own while you do nothing, which is why it’s the one that most often goes wrong on a site that was perfectly good when it launched.

10. It looks professional

Consistent, uncluttered, your own photographs where possible. It comes last because it matters least once the other nine are right — and because a tidy, plain site that answers the questions will out-earn a beautiful one that doesn’t, every time.

That isn’t an argument for an ugly website. It’s an argument for doing these in order.

What makes good website design?

Good website design makes the important things easy to find and easy to read: a clear headline, readable text, strong contrast, plenty of space, your own photos, and one obvious next step on each page. It’s design in service of the visitor’s question, not decoration.

A few principles do most of the work:

  • One message per screen. The first thing people see should say the service and the area. A slider that rotates three messages makes people wait for the one they need.
  • Text people can read. A comfortable size on a phone, dark text on a light background, short paragraphs.
  • Real photos. Your team, your van, your finished jobs. Stock photos of people shaking hands tell a visitor nothing about you.
  • One main action. Call, book or get a quote. A page with six buttons of equal weight has none.
  • Accessible by default. Readable contrast, descriptive links and alt text help disabled visitors, and they make the site easier for everyone.

How can you tell if your website is good?

Test it like a customer, then check the numbers. Look at it on your phone, run three real pages through PageSpeed Insights, ask a stranger the five-second question, and check Search Console for whether people find it. Then count enquiries: a good website brings them in.

Five checks, all free, in about half an hour:

  1. The phone test. Open your site on your own phone, on mobile data, and try to find a price and phone the business. Time it.
  2. The speed test. PageSpeed Insights on your homepage, a service page and a blog post or about page.
  3. The five-second test. Show the homepage to someone who doesn’t know you, then ask what you do and where.
  4. The Google test. In Search Console, check which pages are indexed and which searches you appear for. If your main services don’t show up, that’s the first job.
  5. The enquiry test. How many calls, forms and emails came from the website last month? If you don’t know, that’s the first thing to fix.

What makes a bad website?

Bad websites hide the basics: no clear statement of what the business does, no prices, no phone number on mobile, slow pages, out-of-date information, and nothing that proves the business is real. Most aren’t badly designed. They’re unclear and neglected.

The London surveying site I mentioned at the start is a good example of how a site goes bad without anyone noticing. Nobody did anything wrong. It had been published without a plan, never revisited and never tidied for years. About 29 articles were live at two addresses each, and several services had two or three versions of the same page.

Six months of steady work fixed it: one address per page, overlapping posts merged, 25 new pages answering questions clients were typing into Google, and the main service pages rewritten to answer a buyer’s questions instead of reading like a brochure. Google clicks went from 572 in the 90 days before the work to 2,035 in the most recent 90 days. The case study has the month-by-month numbers.

The other common signs of a bad website:

  • “Welcome to our website” as the headline, or a slogan that could be any business.
  • No prices anywhere, so people assume the worst and leave.
  • A contact form and nothing else, with no phone number, area or name.
  • Out-of-date information: last year’s prices, staff who’ve left, a copyright year from 2019.
  • A heavy theme and a pile of plugins making every page slow to load.
  • A blog that stopped after three posts in 2021.

If you’re planning a new site and want it built that way from the start, with keyword research behind every page and someone looking after it afterwards, that’s what my new website service does.

Common questions

What are the 7 C's of a website?

It's a framework from e-commerce teaching: context (layout and design), content, community, customisation, communication, connection (links to and from other sites) and commerce. It's a useful prompt for big online businesses. For a small business I'd boil it down to two questions: can people find you, and once they arrive, can they see quickly that you're the right choice and get in touch?

Does a good website need a blog?

Not always. A small local business can do well with strong service pages, real reviews and a good Google Business Profile. A blog earns its place when customers research before they buy and ask questions you can answer better than anyone else. How to plan SEO content covers how to decide.

How much does a good website cost?

A professionally built small business site usually costs about £1,200 to £5,500 plus VAT in the UK, and a DIY builder is £0 to £50 a month. How much a website costs breaks down UK and US prices, and what pushes them up.

Is Wix or WordPress better for a small business website?

Either can make a good website, and either can make a slow, confusing one. Wix and Squarespace are easier to run yourself; WordPress is more flexible and has more people who can work on it, but it slows down as plugins pile up. The platform matters less than the pages, the speed and whether anyone looks after it.

How often should a website be updated?

Check prices, opening hours, services and contact details whenever they change, and look over the whole site at least every few months. Add or improve pages when Search Console shows people searching for something you don't answer. A site nobody has touched in three years usually shows it.

Want to hand your site over to a professional?

Everything above is yours to run with. If you'd rather someone else ran it, send me the address and I'll tell you what I'd fix first — free, and in plain English.

Get a free SEO audit